Alex Reben’s work is commonly absurd, sometimes surreal: a mash-up of giant ears imagined by DALL-E and sculpted by hand out of marble; critical burns generated by ChatGPT that thumb the nose in any respect AI art. But its message is relevant to everyone. Reben is taken with the roles humans play in a world crammed with machines, and the way those roles are changing.
“I form of use humor and absurdity to take care of numerous these issues,” says Reben. “Some artists may come at things head-on in a really serious manner, but I find for those who’re slightly absurd it makes the ideas more approachable, even when the story you’re attempting to tell may be very serious.”
Reben is OpenAI’s first artist in residence. Officially, the appointment began in January and lasts three months. But Reben’s relationship with the San Francisco–based AI firm seems casual: “It’s slightly fuzzy, because I’m the primary, and we’re figuring stuff out. I’m probably going to maintain working with them.”
The truth is, Reben has been working with OpenAI for years already. Five years ago, he was invited to check out an early version of GPT-3 before it was released to the general public. “I got to mess around with that quite a bit and made a couple of artworks,” he says. “They were quite taken with seeing how I could use their systems in alternative ways. And I used to be like, cool, I’d like to try something latest, obviously. Back then I used to be mostly making stuff with my very own models or using web sites like Ganbreeder [a precursor of today’s generative image-making models].”
In 2008, Reben studied math and robotics at MIT’s Media Lab. There he helped create a cardboard robot called Boxie, which inspired the lovable robot Baymax within the movie . He’s now director of technology and research at Stochastic Labs, a nonprofit incubator for artists and engineers in Berkeley, California. I spoke to Reben via Zoom about his work, the unresolved tension between art and technology, and the longer term of human creativity.
Our conversation has been edited for length and clarity.
You’re taken with ways in which humans and machines interact. As an AI artist, how would you describe what you do with technology? Is it a tool, a collaborator?
Firstly, I don’t call myself an AI artist. AI is just one other technological tool. If something comes along after AI that interests me, I wouldn’t, like, say, “Oh, I’m only an AI artist.”
Okay. But what’s it about these AI tools? Why have you ever spent your profession fooling around with this type of technology?
My research on the Media Lab was all about social robotics, taking a look at how people and robots come together in alternative ways. One robot [Boxie] was also a filmmaker. It principally interviewed people, and we found that the robot was making people speak in confidence to it and tell it very deep stories. This was pre-Siri, or anything like that. Today persons are accustomed to the concept of talking to machines. So I’ve at all times been taken with how humanity and technology co-evolve over time. You realize, we’re who we’re today due to technology.
Straight away, there’s numerous pushback against using AI in art. There’s numerous comprehensible unhappiness about technology that enables you to just press a button and get a picture. Individuals are unhappy that these tools were even made and argue that the makers of those tools, like OpenAI, should perhaps carry some more responsibility. But here you might be, immersed within the art world, continuing to make fun, engaging art. I’m wondering what your experience of those sorts of conversations has been?
Yeah. In order I’m sure you realize, being within the media, the negative voices are at all times louder. The people who find themselves using these tools in positive ways aren’t quite as loud sometimes.
But, I mean, it’s also a really wide issue. People take a negative view for many alternative reasons. Some people worry in regards to the data sets, some people worry about job alternative. Other people worry about, you realize, disinformation and the world being flooded with media. And so they’re all valid concerns.
Once I speak about this, I am going to the history of photography. What we’re seeing today is essentially a parallel of what happened back then. There aren’t any longer artists who paint products for a living—like, who paint cans of peaches for an commercial in a magazine or on a billboard. But that was a job, right? Photography eliminated that swath of parents.
You realize, you used the phrase—I wrote it down—“just press a button and get a picture,” which also jogs my memory of photography. Anyone can push a button and get a picture, but to be a fine-art photographer, it takes numerous skill. Simply because artwork is quick to make doesn’t necessarily mean it’s any worse than, like, someone sculpting something for 60 years out of marble. They’re various things.
AI is moving fast. We’ve moved past the equivalent of wet-plate photography using cyanide. But we’re actually not within the Polaroid phase quite yet. We’re still coming to terms with what this implies, each in a fine-art sense but in addition for jobs.
But, yeah, your query has so many facets. We could pick any considered one of them and go at it. There’s definitely numerous valid concerns on the market. But I also think taking a look at the history of technology, and the way it’s actually empowered artists and other people to make latest things, is significant as well.
There’s one other line of argument that if you might have a potentially infinite supply of AI-generated images, it devalues creativity. I’m interested by the balance you see in your work between what you do and what the technology does for you. How do you relate that balance to this query of value, and where we discover value in art?
Sure, value in art—there’s an economic sense and there’s a critical sense, right? In an economic sense, you possibly can tape a banana to a wall and sell it for 30,000 dollars. It’s just who’s willing to purchase it or whatever.
In a critical sense, again, going back to photography, the world is flooded with images and there are still people making great photography on the market. And there are individuals who set themselves apart by doing something that’s different.
I mess around with those ideas. Slightly bit like—you realize, the plunger work was the primary one. I got GPT to explain an artwork that didn’t exist; then I made it. Which type of flips the concept of authorship on his head but still required me to undergo hundreds of outputs to seek out one which was funny enough to make.
Back then GPT wasn’t a chatbot. I spent month coming up with the start bits of texts—like, wall labels next to art in museums—and getting GPT to finish them.
I also really like your ear sculpture, . It’s a sculpture described by GPT-3, visualized by DALL-E, and carved out of marble by a robot. It’s form of like a waterfall, with one form of software feeding the subsequent.
When text-to-image got here out, it made obvious sense to feed it the descriptions of artworks I’d been generating. It’s a series, form of backwards and forwards, human to machine back to human. That ear, particularly: it starts with an outline that’s fed into DALL-E, but then that image was was a 3D model by a human 3D artist.
After that it was carved by robots. However the robots get only thus far with the detail, so human sculptors should are available in and finish it by hand. I’ve made 10 or 15 permutations of this, twiddling with those back-and-forths, chaining technology together. And the ultimate thing that happens now could be that I’ll take an image of the artwork and get GPT-4 to create the wall label for it.
Yeah, that keeps coming up in your work, different ways in which humans and machines interact.
You realize, I made some videos of the technique of these items being made to point out what number of artisans were employed within the making of these items. There are still huge industries where I can see AI increasing work for people, who will make stuff that it comes up with.
I’m also struck by the serendipity that usually comes with generative tools, making art out of something random. Do you see a connection between your work and located art or ready-mades, like Duchamp’s ? I mean, you are perhaps not only coming across a urinal and pondering, “Oh, that is cool.” But while you mess around with these tools, sooner or later you need to get something presented to you that you just react to and think, “Oh, I can use that.”
Needless to say. Yeah, it actually jogs my memory slightly bit more of street photography, which I used to do once I was in college in Latest York City, where you’d just form of roam around and wait for something to encourage you. Then you definitely’d set yourself as much as capture the image in the best way that you just wanted. It’s form of like that obviously. There’s definitely a curatorial process to it. There’s a technique of finding things, which I believe is interesting.
We talked about photography. Photography modified the art that got here after it. You realize, you had movements where people desired to attempt to get at a reality that wasn’t photographic reality—things like Impressionism, and Cubism or Picasso. Do you’re thinking that we’ll see something similar happening due to AI?
I believe so. Any latest artistic tool definitely changes the sphere as people determine not only methods to use that tool but methods to differentiate themselves from what that tool can do.
Talking of AI as a tool—do you’re thinking that that art will at all times be something made by humans? That irrespective of how good the tech gets, it can at all times just be a tool? You realize, the best way you’ve strung together these different AIs—you possibly can try this without being within the loop. You might just have some form of curator AI at the tip that chooses what it likes best. Would that ever be art?
I even have a few works during which an AI creates a picture, uses the image to create a brand new image, and just keeps going. But I believe even in a super-automated process you possibly can return far enough to seek out some human somewhere who made a choice to do something. Like, perhaps they selected what data set to make use of.
We’d see hotel rooms crammed with robot paintings. I mean, stuff we hardly even take a look at, that never even makes its way through human curation.
I assume the query is basically how much human involvement is required to make something art. Is there a threshold or, like, a percentage of involvement? It’s query.
Yeah, I assume it’s like, is it still art if there’s nobody there to see it?
You realize, what’s and isn’t art is considered one of those questions that has been asked endlessly. I believe more to the purpose is: What is sweet art versus bad art? And that’s very personal.
But I believe humans are at all times going to be doing these things. We’ll still be painting within the very far future.